Kerbside Consult

From Buying Technology to Building It — Lessons for Malaysia

Cyberdoc — writing on medicine since 1995

83/2026 · 22 November 2026 · Kuala Lumpur

A recent journey along China’s remarkable G65 Baomao Expressway left me thinking about more than tunnels and highways. Behind such engineering achievements lie decades of investment in knowledge, research and skilled people.

Malaysia has its own impressive accomplishments, from tunnelling innovation to advanced manufacturing. But are we doing enough to develop technologies of our own? And what can we learn from countries that have made the transition from buying technology to creating it?

Editorial illustration of a mountain expressway, bridges and tunnels, inspired by mountain expressways in China.AI-generated illustration
Illustration inspired by mountain expressways in China. AI-generated artwork; not a photograph of any particular road.

Contents

  1. A journey through the mountains
  2. From buying machines to building them
  3. Malaysia's tunnelling achievements
  4. MRT, railways and highways
  5. Other industrial successes
  6. Why not more R&D?
  7. The automotive question
  8. What about healthcare?
  9. What should Malaysia aim for?
  10. Back to the mountains
  11. At the kerbside
  12. Sources & further reading

A journey through the mountains

During my recent visit to China, we travelled from Chongqing to Wulong Karst along the G65 Baomao Expressway, via Nanchuan. I later learned that the G65 is no ordinary highway: it stretches roughly 3,000 kilometres from Baotou in Inner Mongolia to Maoming in southern China. In Chongqing it runs from Jieshi in Banan District through Nanchuan to Wulong, the stretch we travelled; the Jieshi–Nanchuan section opened in 2007 and the Nanchuan–Wulong section in 2009.[1]

What struck me most was the succession of tunnels through the mountains. We would emerge briefly into daylight, cross a bridge or travel along a mountainside, and then disappear into another tunnel. I estimated that we must have travelled through nearly 40 kilometres of tunnels.

Later, I came across engineering documentation for the approximately 135-kilometre Jieshi–Wulong expressway section, listing 14 tunnels with a combined length of approximately 39.83 kilometres. The longest, Baiyun Tunnel, measures approximately 7.2 kilometres. These are figures for the documented expressway section, not a measurement of the distance our vehicle travelled inside tunnels. (The operator's own summary page gives slightly different subtotals, about 36.6 km; I have used the detailed tunnel table in the engineering drawings, whose entries add up to 39.83 km.) My impression was not far off.[2]

There is now a second route through these mountains. A new parallel Chongqing–Hunan expressway, fully open since December 2025, meets the G65 at the Shuijiang North interchange, and about 80 percent of its 280 kilometres runs on bridges or through tunnels.[3], [4], [5] We did not travel it.

It was not simply the number or length of the tunnels that impressed me. I wondered about the planning, engineering knowledge, machinery and skilled workforce required to build such a transport network. It brought to mind China's transformation from dependence on imported advanced tunnelling machinery to becoming a major manufacturer of its own.

The tunnels were only one example of how far, and how fast, China has moved. Wherever we went, the same thing struck me. Cities crowded with skyscrapers. Roads and railways that simply worked. And a system that let us, as foreign visitors, use our passports as our tickets once we had bought them, whether for the train or for a park. No paper ticket was needed at all.

None of that happens by accident. Behind the convenience lie planning, technology and systems that talk to each other, built over years.

And that led me to another question. What about Malaysia? We have been industrialising for decades, attracting international manufacturers and developing considerable technical expertise. Yet how much of the technology behind our industries do we actually develop and own?

Selected references: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5.

From buying machines to building them

China's tunnelling industry offers a useful lesson. In the 1990s and early 2000s, it relied heavily on imported advanced tunnelling machinery, particularly from established German and Japanese manufacturers. A Japanese maker's 2001 announcement of a shield machine order for Tianjin's metro, for instance, noted that stable, long-term demand was expected as several Chinese cities built subways.[6] Buying the machines was one thing. Learning to design and build them was far harder.

China invested in engineering research, technical training and domestic manufacturing. In 2008, China Railway developed China Railway No. 1, a modern earth-pressure-balance shield machine with domestically developed intellectual property. It began work on a metro project in Tianjin on 6 February 2009. This was not China's first tunnelling research, but an important milestone in modern shield-machine development.[7], [8] One of its makers later described the effort as six years of independent research.[9]

Two things stand out. First, there was a very large and steady home market: dozens of cities building metros gave domestic makers somewhere to test, fail and improve. Second, the effort was sustained for years rather than a single project or budget cycle. Both are easier to say than to copy.

There is also an irony that Malaysian readers may enjoy. China's first exported domestically produced TBM followed a China Railway win on a Kuala Lumpur metro project,[8] and two TBMs built by China Railway Engineering Equipment Group (CR-50 and CR-51) each bored a 2,814-metre tunnel for the Klang Valley MRT, breaking through in October 2014.[10] Our MRT was, in effect, an early customer for China's shield-machine industry.

We should distinguish these machines from the construction methods used for mountain highway tunnels. Many road tunnels are excavated by drilling, blasting and other techniques rather than large urban-rail TBMs. Both, however, depend on accumulated engineering expertise, specialised suppliers and long-term investment.

Selected references: 6, 7, 8, 9, 10.

Malaysia's tunnelling achievements

It would be unfair to say Malaysia has only bought its technology. In tunnelling, we have done more than that.

Consider Kuala Lumpur's SMART Tunnel, opened in 2007. Combining stormwater management with a road tunnel, it addressed two difficult urban problems: flooding and traffic congestion. Its design and construction required considerable engineering ingenuity.[11]

The Klang Valley MRT went further. Kuala Lumpur's unpredictable limestone formations and underground cavities make tunnelling particularly challenging. Malaysian engineers from MMC-Gamuda worked with Germany's Herrenknecht to develop the world's first Variable Density Tunnel Boring Machine, launched in 2013. It was designed to handle difficult karstic ground conditions. This was genuine international technological collaboration, not simply the purchase of an off-the-shelf machine.[12]

Gamuda subsequently developed AI-based control software for autonomous TBM operation, first used on the Sydney Metro West tunnelling package, where two Herrenknecht-built machines are steered, operated and monitored by Gamuda's software.[13], [14] Note the distinction: the machines came from a German partner, while the intelligence that runs them is Malaysian. Gamuda also runs specialist tunnelling training.[13]

We do not manufacture complete TBMs on the scale of the world's largest producers. But Malaysian engineers have shown they can help create original technology. The harder question is how to repeat it.

Selected references: 11, 12, 13, 14.

MRT, railways and highways

Malaysia has substantial experience constructing MRT and LRT systems, electrified double-track railway lines, highways, bridges and complex urban infrastructure. Malaysian engineering companies have also delivered major projects overseas.

Our rail industry has acquired expertise in train assembly, maintenance, repair and systems integration. Yet much of the advanced rolling stock, propulsion, signalling and train-control technology still comes from overseas manufacturers.

There is a difference between constructing a railway, assembling a train and developing the technology that makes the train operate. All require expertise, but they are not the same level of technological ownership. Similarly, our highway construction achievements do not mean that every piece of specialised equipment or control system is locally designed.

Recognising that distinction is not a criticism of Malaysian engineers. It helps us identify where to invest next.

Other industrial successes

Medical gloves

Malaysia became one of the world's leading producers of medical gloves. Companies such as Top Glove, Hartalega and Kossan developed sophisticated manufacturing operations, automation and quality control. The industry's global market share was put at approximately 45% in 2024, ahead of China at about 28%.[15], [16]

That lead has not proved permanent. Analysts at TA Research estimate that Chinese makers raised their share from about 11% in 2019 to around 34% in 2025, while Malaysia's fell from about 63% to roughly 35%.[17] Other analysts, writing in August 2026, remain unconvinced that tariffs on Chinese gloves will bring a recovery.[18] Estimates differ by source and method, so treat the figures as indicative. The lesson for this article is plain. Knowing how to make something efficiently can be copied. Staying ahead takes continuing innovation.

Semiconductors

Malaysia has participated in the global semiconductor industry for more than five decades. Penang and other centres have developed considerable expertise in assembly, testing and packaging. Bank Negara Malaysia and MIDA both put Malaysia's share of global assembly, testing and packaging activity at about 13%, an official estimate for which neither gives a base year.[19] These are technically demanding operations, but there remains room to capture more value through original chip design, advanced engineering and intellectual property.

Policy is now pointing that way. The National Semiconductor Strategy of May 2024 set out RM25 billion in fiscal support, training for 60,000 engineers and at least 10 local design and advanced-packaging firms with revenues of RM1–4.7 billion.[20] In March 2025 Malaysia signed a national partnership with Arm to train 10,000 IC design engineers and give selected Malaysian companies access to Arm's technology,[21] reportedly paying US$250 million over 10 years for chip designs and IP.[22] Here is our theme again, in miniature: buying technology as a deliberate step towards building it. Licensing first has been a route many latecomers have used, but it only pays off if local firms go on to design products the world wants to buy.

Precision engineering

Homegrown companies such as ViTrox, Greatech, Pentamaster and UWC are described by MIDA as delivering automation platforms, automated optical inspection systems, precision engineering tools and cleanroom and handling systems for semiconductor fabrication and advanced packaging lines. These are firms making equipment, not simply operating imported machinery.[23]

We rightly celebrate foreign companies investing in Malaysian factories. We should also celebrate Malaysian companies that create technologies for the world market.

Selected references: 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23.

Why not more R&D?

Let us start with the number. Malaysia's R&D spending is modest. The latest national R&D survey (it is biennial) reports expenditure of RM18.16 billion in 2022, equivalent to 1.01% of GDP.[24], [25]

That was short of the national target. The National Science, Technology and Innovation Policy aimed for 2.5% of GDP by 2025 and 3.5% by 2030.[26] An Auditor-General report in early 2026 found that only one of the six 12th Malaysia Plan objectives had been met by June 2025; only experimental research expenditure met its target (60.97% against a 50% goal). The unmet objectives included GERD as a share of GDP, business expenditure on R&D, researchers per 10,000 of the labour force, a top-20 Global Innovation Index ranking and citizen patent applications; and only 34.1% of the projects audited were physically completed.[27]

How does that compare internationally? In 2024, South Korea devoted approximately 5.1% of GDP to R&D, Japan 3.6%, the United States 3.4%, Germany 3.1% and China 2.7%. These figures are from a later year than Malaysia's and should be read as a broad benchmark rather than a same-year ranking.[28]

Within ASEAN, Malaysia compares more favourably. Singapore invests more, while Thailand's reported level is relatively close. Vietnam, Indonesia and the Philippines have reported lower levels in the available international series, although some observations are older.[29] Malaysia is not among the region's weakest performers. The larger gap is with economies that have built research-intensive industries.

There is also encouraging news. In the 2022 survey, industry's share of national R&D spending rose to about 51%, from 34% in 2020.[25] Business is moving in the right direction. The question is whether that spending is producing technologies that Malaysian firms own and sell.

Why does this gap persist?

Part of the explanation, I suspect, lies in our industrial structure. We have attracted multinational manufacturers, but some of their original research and product design remain overseas. Smaller Malaysian businesses may lack the capital and specialist staff for projects that take years to produce returns. Buying proven technology is often safer than developing something new.

Universities face another challenge. A promising discovery does not automatically become a product. It needs further development, testing, investment, manufacturing and customers. Academic incentives and commercial needs do not always align. Research also requires continuity: programmes cannot mature if priorities and support repeatedly change.

More government spending alone is not the answer. Businesses must keep investing in developing their own technologies, and universities need stronger industry partnerships. We should measure not only how much is spent, but how many useful technologies emerge, reach the market and compete internationally.

Selected references: 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30.

The automotive question

PROTON and Perodua helped develop local manufacturing, component suppliers, engineering expertise and skilled employment. These achievements deserve recognition. Yet international exports have been modest compared with major Japanese, Korean and Chinese manufacturers. A 2024 MITI statement, based on information from the two manufacturers, reported that they exported 24,272 vehicles from 2019 to September 2024.[31] Of these, 17,118 were PROTON and 7,154 Perodua.[32] Over roughly five and three-quarter years, that averages about 4,200 vehicles a year (my arithmetic).

The reasons are complex, including market size, policy, partnerships and commercial strategy. Partnerships deserve a word. In 2017 China's Geely took a 49.9% stake in PROTON,[33] and the arrangement included platform-sharing, with PROTON's first SUV to be developed from Geely's Boyue.[34] That is a rational commercial decision, and the cars sell. It is also, plainly, a case of acquiring technology rather than building it, in the very industry where Malaysia once set out to do the latter.

The lesson is not that Malaysia achieved nothing, but that building a domestic manufacturing industry and becoming a globally competitive technology producer are different accomplishments.

Selected references: 31, 32, 33, 34.

What about healthcare?

Malaysia has a substantial medical device manufacturing sector, producing everything from gloves and instruments to specialised components.[35] Yet much advanced hospital equipment — MRI and CT scanners, surgical robots and sophisticated laboratory analysers — is developed abroad.

Building research infrastructure is one achievement; turning Malaysian discoveries into widely used products is another. (I looked at the first of these in an earlier Kerbside Consult article, Medical Research in Malaysia: From Participant to Contributor, 40/2026, 5 October 2026.)

There is nothing wrong with purchasing the best equipment for patients, nor would it make sense to manufacture everything ourselves. But medical diagnostics, rehabilitation devices, digital health and selected biotechnology applications offer opportunities for original Malaysian innovation.

Our clinicians, scientists and engineers could work more closely together. Sometimes innovation begins not with a billion-ringgit programme, but with a clinician asking whether there is a better way to solve a problem. The difficult part is turning that idea into a safe, effective and commercially viable product.

Selected references: 35.

What should Malaysia aim for?

Malaysia does not need technological self-sufficiency in every field. Even advanced economies rely on international collaboration and global supply chains. Our aim should be to build stronger capabilities where we already have expertise and realistic opportunities to compete.

The examples in this article suggest three practical levers.

That also means sustained investment in education and research, closer university–industry collaboration, rewarding skilled people, and helping companies develop original technology. Foreign investment and new factories matter, but they are not the whole measure.

Back to the mountains

As I think back to our journey between Chongqing and Wulong, it is the tunnels I remember. Each was a hard engineering problem, solved. Together they made a difficult mountain road look easy. Above Wulong, Fairy Mountain rises to 2,033 metres,[36] and its forest park averages about 1,900 metres.[37]

But the deeper achievement was the knowledge, people, suppliers and long-term investment that made the tunnels possible.

Malaysia has the talent. Our work in tunnelling, precision engineering, medical gloves and semiconductors shows it. The challenge is not to start from nothing, but to build on what we have, and to create more opportunities for the next generation.

Selected references: 36, 37.

At the kerbside

Malaysia has real engineering achievements to point to: the SMART Tunnel, the Variable Density TBM, Gamuda's autonomous-TBM software, and precision-equipment makers selling to the world. Against that, R&D spending was 1.01% of GDP in 2022, against a national target of 2.5% by 2025, and the Auditor-General found the GERD objective unmet by June 2025. Industry's share of that spending is, encouragingly, rising.

Leads built on manufacturing know-how, as in gloves, can erode. Ownership of design, software and intellectual property lasts longer. Buying technology is not a failure; what matters is whether it becomes a step towards building our own.

A country's technological progress should not be measured only by the sophisticated equipment it can afford to buy, but also by the knowledge it develops and the technologies its people can create.

That, to me, is the real lesson from those tunnels through the mountains of China.

Sources & further reading

  1. Baidu Baike. Baotou–Maoming Expressway (3,008 km; user-edited; accessed 22 November 2026): entry; Wikipedia, G65 Baotou–Maoming Expressway (3,017 km when complete). Published figures differ slightly.
  2. Chongqing Expressway Group. G65 Chongqing–Wulong expressway tunnel-group improvement project. 2022. Official source. Tunnel inventory (14 tunnels, 39,831.717 m, Jieshi–Wulong, the older G65 route): Chongqing–Wulong engineering drawings. The operator's narrative page gives slightly different subtotals (about 36.6 km); the figures describe the G65 route we travelled.
  3. Xinhua / China Daily. New sections of 2nd Chongqing-Hunan expressway open to public traffic. 3 January 2025. Source.
  4. Xinhua / Hunan Provincial Government. Second Chongqing-Hunan Expressway Fully Operational. 23 December 2025 (80 percent of the 280-km line on bridges or in tunnels). Source.
  5. China Media Group (Huanqiu). 渝湘复线高速巴南至武隆段、彭水至酉阳段正式建成通车 [Banan–Wulong and Pengshui–Youyang sections of the Chongqing–Hunan second expressway open; in Chinese]. 2 January 2025 (interchange with the G65 at Shuijiang North). Source.
  6. Kawasaki Heavy Industries. TBM Goes to China Again (Tianjin Metro Line 1 extension order). 20 December 2001. Source.
  7. China Railway Group. History of China's shield tunnelling technology. 2026. Source.
  8. Hunan Provincial Government. China's Tunnel Boring Machine (TBM) — A Pillar of the Great Power (timeline: China Railway No. 1 debut 2008, started work on a metro project in Tianjin on 6 February 2009; first exported domestically produced TBM after a Kuala Lumpur metro win, 2012). Source.
  9. China Daily. China Railway Engineering Equipment Group's shield tunnelling machine. 29 August 2023. Source.
  10. tunnel-online. Klang Valley MRT Project: Breakthrough of CREG EPB TBMs (CR-51 and CR-50; 2,814 m each; 6,670 mm excavation diameter; breakthroughs 21 and 29 October 2014). Source.
  11. SMART. Stormwater Management and Road Tunnel. Official website.
  12. MRT Corp. World's First Variable Density Tunnel Boring Machine Launched. 2013. Source.
  13. Gamuda Berhad. Tunnelling Innovation. Source.
  14. Sydney Metro. Australia's first autonomous tunnel boring machines to be used on Sydney Metro West. 31 March 2022. Source; and Gamuda, M'sian technology goes to Sydney (Herrenknecht machines, Gamuda-developed AI).
  15. Malaysian Rubber Glove Manufacturers Association. Malaysia Set to Grab Bigger Share of US Glove Market with New Trump Tariffs on China Goods. 24 February 2025 (reproducing a New Straits Times report: Malaysia about 45% and China about 28% in 2024). Source. Association-reported figure, relayed via a newspaper.
  16. The Sun. Rubber glove export value set to rise (45% global share in 2024, 11th International Rubber Glove Conference). Source.
  17. Borneo Post. Threats still linger for rubber glovemakers (TA Research). 20 January 2026. Source.
  18. The Edge Malaysia. Glove makers' efforts to regain market share yet to bear fruit. 25 August 2026. Source.
  19. Bank Negara Malaysia. Malaysia's Position in the Global E&E Value Chain and Prospects. Economic & Monetary Review 2024. Source. States a 13% share of global assembly, testing and packaging (ATP) activity; the page gives no year or basis for the figure (it cites a table image). The same estimate appears in MIDA material since at least February 2024 and was still being attributed to MIDA in Malay Mail, 4 September 2026.
  20. Malaysian Investment Development Authority. PM Anwar: Malaysia to train, upskill 60,000 engineers, allocate RM25b in fiscal support for National Semiconductor Strategy. 28 May 2024. Source; targets (at least 10 local design and advanced-packaging firms, revenues RM1–4.7 billion; 100 related firms; RM500 billion investment target) at MIDA; Ministry of Investment, Trade and Industry. National Semiconductor Strategy (PDF). 2024.
  21. Malaysian Investment Development Authority. MIDA and ARM Limited forge agreement to boost Malaysia's semiconductor industry. 5 March 2025. Source.
  22. TechCrunch. ARM to sign $250M chip deal with Malaysia. 5 March 2025. Source.
  23. Malaysian Investment Development Authority. Beyond Assembly Lines: Powering Malaysia's Rise in Semiconductor and High-Tech Frontiers. 2 October 2025. Also gives 13% of global ATP volume; names ViTrox, Greatech, Pentamaster and UWC. Source.
  24. Malaysian Science and Technology Information Centre. Research and Development Indicators. Source.
  25. Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation. Media release on the National Survey of R&D, financial year 2022. 17 July 2025. Source (PDF).
  26. MIDA. Nearly RM86 bln in R&D investment needed to achieve NSTIP targets: MOSTI. Source.
  27. The Star. Five of six 12MP goals missed, reveals AG report (Auditor-General's Report 1/2026). 25 February 2026. Source. Newspaper report of the audit; the report itself was not read.
  28. National Science Board. The State of U.S. Science and Engineering 2026. Source. Figures for the United States, China, Japan, Germany and South Korea read directly in the report (section "R&D Intensity", p. 45; published 4 May 2026; Figure 22 is "2024 or most recent year"). Also corroborated for South Korea, Japan and China by The Edge Malaysia, 21 August 2026: Source.
  29. World Bank / UNESCO Institute for Statistics. Research and development expenditure (% of GDP). Source. Thailand (0.94% of GDP in 2023, down from 1.16% in 2022): National Research Council of Thailand, Thailand's Research and Development Index (2023 survey; GERD/GDP 0.94%).
  30. National Research Foundation Singapore. National Survey of Research, Innovation and Enterprise 2023. Source (PDF).
  31. MIDA. Govt offers various initiatives, incentives to drive local automotive industry, says MITI. 18 November 2024. Source.
  32. Bernama. Govt offers various initiatives, incentives to drive local automotive industry – MITI (Proton/Perodua split). 18 November 2024. Source.
  33. New Straits Times. It's official: Geely acquires 49pct stake in Proton. 24 May 2017. Source.
  34. The Star. Proton and Geely agreement (platform-sharing, Boyue). 25 May 2017. Source.
  35. Malaysian Investment Development Authority. Medical Technology — Medical Devices. Source.
  36. Chongqing Municipal People's Government. Wulong Karst Tourism Area (Three Natural Bridges · Fairy Mountain · Furong Cave). 11 June 2026. Source.
  37. China Daily. Karst Landscape, Wulong. 17 December 2018. Source.

Published 83/2026 · 22 November 2026 · No corrections to date · Corrections policy