My maternal uncle, S. Kathiravale, was a self-made man who achieved many firsts, yet to me he was always a very humble person. He was a live wire at any party, forever cracking jokes, and we sometimes called him the “in-between joker” because he could always fill a gap or come back with a better joke.
You may be wondering why his story appears on Kerbside Consult. He was one of Malaysia’s quiet sporting pioneers. Above all he was a good teacher, one who rose to international fame and passed on his wisdom to the countless referees he trained and coached around the world, mainly in broader Asia.
Some careers are measured in trophies. His was measured in whistles, flags and a great many classrooms. S. Kathiravale (Kathiravale Saravanamuthu, the initial being his father’s name) was born in Seremban, Negeri Sembilan, on 1 October 1929 and died in Kuala Lumpur on 12 June 2013. By profession he was a schoolteacher for 33 years; by vocation he was a referee and an umpire, and the two roles were never far apart. Malaysian referees knew him as Mahaguru, the master teacher of the Laws of the Game.
Contents
A double international
He held international credentials in two sports. He was an FIH international hockey umpire from 1968 (Grade I from 1973), and a FIFA international referee from 1971 to 1980. The Asian Football Confederation (AFC) also records him as an AFC referee instructor from 1975 to 2000, one of the first three, and a FIFA referee instructor from 1986 to 2000 [1].
The matches he was given tell the story:
- 1972: referee of the AFC Asian Cup final in Bangkok on 19 May 1972, when Iran beat South Korea 2–1 after extra time [1], [8].
- 1975: the final of the first AFC Women's Championship, in Hong Kong. New Zealand beat Thailand [1], [2].
- 1975: five matches at the hockey World Cup in Kuala Lumpur [3], where he was one of two Malaysian umpires [10].
- 1977: the Japan v South Korea World Cup qualifier in Tokyo [1].
- 1978: senior linesman in the Asian Games football final in Bangkok, South Korea v North Korea [3]. That final ended level, and the gold was shared [4].
Two finals, two sports
The distinction his family treasures is this: he took part in the finals of two different sports at two successive Asian Games. In 1974 in Tehran he umpired the India v Pakistan hockey final, which was drawn and replayed the next day, Pakistan winning the replay [1], [9]. He umpired both the final and the replay, among four matches at those Games [3]. In 1978 in Bangkok he was senior linesman for the football final between Korea Republic and DPR Korea [1].
The AFC's own tribute is careful with the wording. It calls him "perhaps the only Malaysian" to have officiated at Asian Games finals in two sports [1]. I will keep to that wording. "Only person in the world" is a claim that has not been tested, and I would rather the record be right than large.
The classroom never left
He ran referee courses and seminars in more than 34 countries for FIFA, the AFC and national bodies. The FIFA FUTURO courses alone, between 1993 and 2000, took him from Jakarta and Colombo to Pyongyang, Almaty, Mongolia and Guam [3]. Most of it was done alongside a full teaching career.
Recognition
The Olympic Council of Malaysia inducted him into its Hall of Fame on 16 December 2011 [3], [6], [13]. The AFC gave him its Distinguished Service Award in Kuala Lumpur on 14 May 1998, signed by its president, Sultan Ahmad Shah, and general secretary, Dato' Peter Velappan, and presented a further award in May 2000 for his years as a referee instructor [3], [13]. The FIFA Referees' Committee awarded him its Special Award in Zurich in March 1982, in recognition of his merit as a national and international referee and of his outstanding work as a referee instructor [3], [13]. He received the FIFA 100th Year Special Service Award in 2004, and on 3 May 2013, about six weeks before he died, the AFC conferred its Golden Star service award on him at its 25th Congress in Kuala Lumpur [1], [12], [13]. The Malaysian Hockey Confederation also honoured him with a certificate of appreciation, Jasamu Dikenang ("your service is remembered"), as a former international umpire [13]. At the time of his death, FIFA and AFC officials in Asia remembered him as the face of Asian refereeing [1].
From the family album
On the field
Recognition
A sporting legacy across generations
S. Kathiravale's career was part of a family tradition that spans three generations.
His father, P. Saravanamuthu, my maternal grandfather, was reportedly involved in football refereeing before independence, including Malaya Cup matches in the early 1930s, according to family records [3]. His identity as Kathiravale's father is independently established by official Malaysian government documentation, although the historical refereeing appointments still await archival confirmation.
Kathiravale himself went on to international recognition in both football and field hockey.
His eldest son, K. Ananthavel (Ananthavale), continued the family's involvement in sporting officiating. Official International Hockey Federation tournament records list him as a Malaysian official at the 2014 Asian Games in Incheon, South Korea, where he appears as a technical officer and as a scoring and timing judge [7]. The family record also lists him as a former international hockey umpire and national football referee [3].
Three generations of the family have given their time to officiating, and that is a legacy in its own right.
What is still to be checked
The family has listed 18 possible "firsts" or "onlys" for him, across four levels: the world (5), Asia (4), ASEAN (3) and Malaysia (6). I have graded each by how far the evidence goes, and I will not claim any until a governing body has confirmed it.
| Grade | Meaning | World | Asia | ASEAN | Malaysia | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | Confirmed as a "first" or "only" by a governing body | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| B | Supported by an independent source, with its own hedge (the AFC's "one of the first three" and "perhaps the only Malaysian") | 0 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 2 |
| C | The appointments are documented, but whether he was first or only has not been tested | 4 | 2 | 0 | 1 | 7 |
| D | Family record only; no independent source yet | 1 | 1 | 3 | 4 | 9 |
| All candidates | 5 | 4 | 3 | 6 | 18 | |
The 18, with their grades:
World (5)
- First person to hold both FIFA international referee and FIH international umpire credentials [C]
- First to officiate men's and women's internationals in both football and hockey [C]
- Only person to officiate Asian Games finals in both football and hockey [C]
- First to officiate finals in two different sports at successive Asian Games (1974 and 1978) [C]
- First dual FIFA–FIH official to become a FIFA referee instructor [D]
Asia (4)
- One of the first three AFC international referee instructors [B]
- First to referee both the men's Asian Cup final (1972) and the first women's Asian Cup final (1975) [C]
- Among the earliest Asian officials to hold FIFA and FIH badges together [D]
- Among the longest-serving AFC referee instructors (25 years, 1975–2000) [C]
ASEAN (3)
- First ASEAN official to referee a men's Asian Cup final [D]
- First ASEAN official qualified as both a football referee and a hockey umpire at international level [D]
- First ASEAN official to referee a women's Asian Cup final [D]
Malaysia (6)
- Only Malaysian to officiate Asian Games finals in two sports [B]
- First Malaysian to hold both FIFA and FIH international credentials [D]
- First Malaysian to officiate men's and women's internationals in both football and hockey [D]
- First Malaysian to referee the men's Asian Cup final and the women's final [D]
- First Malaysian FIFA referee to become a FIFA referee instructor [D]
- Among the earliest Malaysians appointed as AFC referee instructors [C]
The family’s list has 18 entries, but they rest on only five documented facts, each looked at from the world, Asia, ASEAN and Malaysia. Even if only one or two are ever confirmed as firsts, a single career that includes dual FIFA and FIH status, men’s and women’s internationals in both sports, Asian Games finals in two sports, the men’s and women’s Asian Cup finals, and an early place among the AFC’s referee instructors is out of the ordinary, and that does not depend on any record.
So none of the 18 is yet confirmed as a first or only. Two come closest, and both are the AFC's own words: one of the first three AFC referee instructors, and "perhaps the only Malaysian" to officiate Asian Games finals in two sports. The seven in grade C rest on appointments that outside sources document, such as holding both FIFA and FIH credentials and officiating the 1972 and 1975 Asian Cup finals. Whether anyone did them before him is the open question, and it will stay open until the AFC, the OCA, the FIH and the Malaysian bodies can say. If any reader holds old match programmes, badges or newspaper cuttings, I would be glad to hear from you.
Sources & further reading
- AFC, tribute on his passing: the-afc.com
- 1975 AFC Women's Championship: Wikipedia
- S. Kathiravale family biographical profile (document held by the family; not yet independently published)
- Football at the 1978 Asian Games: Wikipedia
- Field hockey at the 1974 Asian Games: Wikipedia
- "A night of sports supremacy", The Star (Metro), 21 December 2011 (family cutting)
- FIH appointment sheets, 17th Asian Games, Incheon 2014 (e.g. men, 27 Sep 2014; women, 26 Sep 2014)
- 1972 AFC Asian Cup final: Wikipedia
- Asian Games OCA Facebook post, "On this day in 1974, Pakistan beat India 2-0 in the Asian Games hockey final": link (read from the author's PDF copy; the replay detail is confirmed by the author, not by the post)
- "Karthiravale, football and hockey's Siu Fu", Level Field blog, June 2013: link
- "Double international official passes away at age 84", The Star, 13 June 2013: link
- "Farewell Kathiravale", National Sports Museum blog, June 2013: link
- Family-held awards, photographed 29 Oct 2026 (PDF: family profile with the award photographs at the end): FIFA Referees' Special Award certificate (Zurich, March 1982; the day is hard to read); AFC Distinguished Service Award certificate (14 May 1998); framed photograph captioned "AFC Distinguished Service Award, 18th May 2000"; OCM Hall of Fame trophy (2011); AFC Golden Star Service Award certificate (3 May 2013) and plaque (25th AFC Congress 2013); Malaysian Hockey Confederation certificate of appreciation (undated in the photograph)
Items 2, 4, 5 and 8 above are Wikipedia summaries. Ideally they should be replaced by RSSSF, OCA or FIH records where possible. I would appreciate it if anyone could send me links to sources so that I can update this. I also look forward to FIFA, the FIH, the AFC and the OCA shedding some light on his possible achievements, so that I can document them and update this article.
