Preamble
A doctor who leaves a government hospital may still be treating patients in Malaysia. Yet the public service loses that doctor's time, experience and contribution to the team. Patients who depend on that service cannot assume that a replacement will arrive with the same skills, in the same place, when needed.
The Ministry of Health's reply to Parliament on 21 October 2026 reported 3,510 resignations among permanent and contract medical officers during 2024–2026. It also recorded 13,072 vacant doctor posts as at 30 June 2026. These figures make retention an urgent question, alongside recruitment: what would make a capable doctor see a future in public healthcare? [1]
What we can say, and what we cannot
The Ministry's figures show resignations, vacant posts and the reasons doctors gave for leaving. They do not show how many left Malaysia, how many went to Singapore, or whether the workforce grew or shrank on balance, so this article keeps resignation, migration and net workforce change apart. [1] My argument is simple: permanent appointments and new posts matter, but public healthcare must earn its doctors' commitment through careers, training and working conditions; it cannot assume it.
1. Leaving MOH is not the same as leaving Malaysia
The parliamentary reply breaks the 3,510 resignations into 1,252 permanent and 2,258 contract medical officers. The larger number among contract officers does not, by itself, establish a higher resignation rate: that comparison would require the relevant workforce denominators and time at risk. [1]
According to MOH's records, the reported reasons were private-sector employment (51.4%), personal reasons (36.8%), service with statutory bodies (4.5%), working or settling overseas (2.9%), health problems (2.6%), further study (1.5%) and opening a clinic (0.3%). The largest recorded category was movement to the private sector. The overseas category is not a national estimate of medical migration, and personal reasons do not establish a doctor's eventual destination. [1]
A doctor joining private practice remains part of Malaysia's healthcare capacity, but is no longer available to MOH on the same terms. Moving to another public institution is different again. We need to understand these movements without treating every departure as emigration or every career change as abandonment of patients.
From my own years as a medical officer in the districts, I know that a post filled on paper is not the same as a clinic with a doctor in it. I considered that gap in The Doctor Who Never Arrived.
As at 30 June 2026, MOH reported 11,412 vacant non-specialist medical officer posts and 1,660 vacant specialist posts, totalling 13,072. These are vacancies in posts, not a population-based estimate of how many doctors Malaysia needs. The reply separately mentions eight medical specialists who had left or moved overseas; that wording does not justify calling all eight emigrants or treating the figure as a complete specialist attrition count. [1]
The reply also records 14,064 permanent and 9,847 contract medical officer appointments during 2024–2026, and 4,500 contract officers offered permanent appointments in 2026. These show recruitment activity, not net additional doctors, because movements between appointment categories and other workforce changes must be reconciled first. [1]
The MOH Annual Report 2025 adds context. At 31 December 2025 it records 8,674 filled permanent medical specialist posts and 27,209 filled permanent medical officer posts, and 12,280 additional permanent posts received during 2025 across all service schemes. [2] Expanding posts is welcome. But a post created, an appointment offered and a doctor continuing to serve are different achievements, and the annual report and the October 2026 reply describe different periods and measures; subtracting one from the other would not establish workforce growth. [1][2]
2. MMA calls for a comprehensive retention strategy
On 23 October 2026, Malaysian Medical Association (MMA) president Dr Sivanaesan Letchumanan called for a comprehensive retention strategy for public healthcare. MMA welcomed the commitment to end the contract doctor system, but urged action on the reasons doctors leave. Its call provides a clear agenda for MOH: review salaries, allowances and on-call pay; establish transparent promotion pathways that recognise experience and qualifications; expand funded Master’s and Parallel Pathway training with transparent, merit-based selection; address excessive workloads through adequate staffing and fairer duties; and protect wellbeing through rest, predictable rosters and workplace support. MMA sought dedicated funding, clear implementation timelines and measurable targets. These are the association’s recommendations, rather than proof that any one factor caused all 3,510 resignations. [3]
The resignations among permanent officers underline why employment status cannot be the whole discussion. A doctor needs to know how expertise will be recognised, whether training is realistically accessible, how postings affect family life, and whether demanding duties are followed by adequate rest. Permanent employment can provide security; the daily experience of work determines whether that security is enough to build a career around.
3. Specialist training exists and its accessibility matters
It would be wrong to suggest that Malaysia offers no structured specialist training. For the 2025/2026 session, the annual report records offers to 1,479 medical officers for the Master of Medicine programme and 240 officers for the Parallel Pathway, a combined 1,719 offers. These are offers, not completed qualifications or additions to the specialist workforce. [2]
The report describes scholarship and study-leave arrangements, including support for specialty and subspecialty training. It records 3,926 Master of Medicine applications and 566 Parallel Pathway applications during a separately described application period. Because the report's session labels and periods do not align clearly with the offer figures, those numbers should not be combined into acceptance rates or used alone to prove a training bottleneck. [2]
The useful policy questions are more specific. How long do eligible doctors wait? Are selection criteria and reasons for decisions clear? Can a trainee obtain supervision, clinical exposure and protected learning time? What proportion complete training, and where do they subsequently serve? Publishing these answers by specialty and region would make both progress and unmet needs visible.
Training capacity is one stage among several. The annual report's Malaysian Medical Council chapter records approvals in 2025 such as 3,172 provisional registrations, 1,866 specialist registrations and 77,093 Annual Practising Certificates. [2] These are regulatory approvals, not groups of newly recruited doctors: 77,093 certificates do not establish 77,093 doctors employed by MOH, and 1,866 specialist registrations are not an equivalent increase in MOH specialists. The parliamentary reply separately reports 6,580 occupied housemanship training slots out of 12,198 across 48 training hospitals, about 54%, and states that graduates were not then waiting for vacant slots. [1] That describes training capacity at that point, not later retention. Producing graduates, approving registration, filling training slots and retaining experienced clinicians are connected tasks, and success at one stage cannot stand in for evidence about the others.
4. A personal reflection on the cost of further training
The questions about selection and support in the previous section are not abstract for me.
In 1989–1990, my wife and I pursued our Master's in Occupational Medicine at the National University of Singapore (NUS).
We had both applied for Malaysian government scholarships but were unsuccessful. Determined to further our education, we took no-pay leave to attend the course.
I was fortunate to receive an ASEAN scholarship, which provided much-needed financial support. There were no strings attached—no requirement to remain in Singapore or serve a particular employer after completing my studies.
At the time, we had a daughter barely one to two years old. She stayed with my in-laws in Malacca while we studied in Singapore. Every week, we travelled to Malacca to spend time with her before returning to our studies.
It was not an easy arrangement. We had given up our salaries temporarily, were living away from our young daughter and depended on family support to pursue our postgraduate qualifications. Looking back, I remain grateful for the opportunity Singapore provided and for the support of our family.
Our experience illustrates something often overlooked in discussions about medical workforce retention. Doctors seeking further qualifications may face considerable financial and family sacrifices, particularly when institutional support is unavailable. It also reminds us that international scholarships are not necessarily instruments of recruitment or permanent migration.
This was a 1989–1990 postgraduate scholarship; it is not today's school-level ASEAN scholarship programme, and it does not establish the scholarship or study-leave rules that now apply to doctors.
If we want doctors to remain committed to public healthcare, we must be prepared to invest in their professional development and recognise the sacrifices made by their families.
5. Listen to students without turning intentions into outcomes
The Malaysian Medical Students' Career Intention study surveyed 859 Malaysian students from 21 medical schools in 2023. Of respondents, 27.1% intended to emigrate; among that group, 80.7% intended to return to Malaysia later. The authors' combined analysis found that 57.5% of all respondents eventually intended a career with MOH. These are different denominators and stages of intended careers. [4]
This voluntary online convenience sample measured intentions, not observed migration or resignation. Selection bias and changing plans limit generalisation; the questionnaire also omitted university and military hospital careers as explicit options. Its findings cannot be projected onto all Malaysian students or used to calculate how many doctors will leave. They do, however, give policymakers a reason to investigate expectations before graduates enter service. [4]
6. Singapore is a real alternative but the numbers have limits
Singapore's MOH reported that, at 31 December 2021, 15,423 doctors held active practising certificates. Of these, 14,367 were citizens or permanent residents; 9,113 of that resident group were locally trained. Among non-resident doctors, 93.1% were foreign-trained, with Malaysia among the main countries of origin named. Citizenship, residency and place of training are different categories. This historical snapshot does not reveal the total number of Malaysian doctors in Singapore or how many recently left Malaysia's public service. [5]
The recruitment infrastructure is visible in primary sources. MOH Holdings describes its central role in recruiting and deploying junior doctors, and publishes medical career tracks. A SingHealth Polyclinics resident physician advertisement dated 24 October 2026 explicitly welcomes overseas-trained doctors with registrable qualifications and describes remuneration and postgraduate sponsorship opportunities. These sources establish an available recruitment route and an employer's offer, not how many Malaysians accepted it. [6][7][8]
Malaysia should examine what makes such opportunities attractive: a credible career path, supported development and recognition of clinical work. Neither an overseas vacancy nor a student's preferred destination is evidence of a completed migration. There is no sound basis here for an estimate of Malaysian doctors lost to Singapore or Australia.
7. Make retention visible where patients receive care
In Malaysia's Health Budget 2027, I asked how allocations could produce better care. Retention connects that question to the gap between a posting on paper and a doctor reaching the community: a funded post matters when a doctor takes it up, receives the support to work effectively and has reason to stay.
MOH should publish a regularly updated workforce account that distinguishes approved and funded posts, occupied posts, actual arrivals, transfers and departures. It should separate permanent and contract officers, specialists and non-specialists, and report staffing by facility and region. Appointment conversions should be identifiable so they are not mistaken for additional clinicians.
A confidential exit process, followed where feasible by later destination checks, would help distinguish private practice, other public institutions, overseas work, training, temporary absence and departure from medicine. Broad reasons should be retained honestly rather than converted into assumed destinations. Cohort follow-up would show whether doctors return after training and whether retention improves over time.
MMA’s call specifically includes transparent, merit-based selection for funded specialist training and the removal of unnecessary administrative barriers. [3] Building on that call, MOH should publish how funded training places and scholarships are allocated: the eligibility rules, selection criteria and decision-making process; the number of applicants and successful candidates by specialty, programme and institution, within Malaysia and overseas; the type and source of funding; and an appeals process. Individual names should be disclosed only where applicable privacy rules and public-sector policy allow. This would allow doctors to understand how opportunities are allocated and assess whether access is fair.
The practical response must reach the workplace. Publish training and promotion criteria, recognise relevant experience fairly, provide predictable rosters and rest, and make relocation and family support part of posting decisions. Give facility leaders the authority and resources to address problems, alongside accountability for results. These are proposals to be evaluated, with retention, staff experience and patient access reported together.
Workplace culture and leadership matter here too. MMA's president said doctors need “a working environment that values their contributions”. [3] That is largely a question of leadership in the ward, the department and the hospital: how seniors teach and support junior colleagues, how duties and leave are decided, and whether staff are treated fairly. Pay and permanent status cannot fully offset a workplace where doctors do not feel supported. I offer this as my own view rather than as a finding from the figures above.
Conclusion
Malaysia is creating posts, offering permanent appointments and supporting postgraduate training. Those efforts deserve recognition. The evidence also shows departures and vacant doctor posts, while leaving important questions about career destinations and long-term retention unanswered. [1][2]
The public healthcare system must learn to stand on its own two feet, like any other institution competing for skilled professionals. It cannot expect doctors to remain simply out of loyalty, a sense of duty or obligation. It must earn their commitment by offering fair remuneration, opportunities for professional advancement, competent and accountable leadership, a supportive working environment and recognition of their contributions.
Permanent appointments provide security, but security alone is not enough. Doctors must see a future in which their careers can develop, their skills are valued and their families' needs are recognised.
The test will be whether the right teams remain in the places that need them—and whether patients receive better care.
References
- Ministry of Health Malaysia. Reply to Tuan Ganabatirau a/l Veraman, Klang. Dewan Rakyat, question 23, 21 October 2026. In: Parliamentary replies JDR21102026. PDF pp. 42–45 [cited 2026 Oct 26]. Primary source.
- Ministry of Health Malaysia. Annual report 2025. Putrajaya: Ministry of Health Malaysia; 2026. Chapter 2, pp. 13–15, 20–21; chapter 17, p. 352, table 17.1 [cited 2026 Oct 26]. English edition. Primary source.
- Statement by Letchumanan S, president, Malaysian Medical Association, 23 Oct 2026, as reported in: (a) Nurul Hidayah Bahaudin. MMA calls for comprehensive strategy to stem exodus of public-sector doctors. New Straits Times [Internet]. 2026 Oct 23 [cited 2026 Oct 27]. MMA-hosted copy; (b) FMT Reporters. Doctors need more than job security, says MMA as 3,500 quit govt service. Free Malaysia Today [Internet]. 2026 Oct 23 [cited 2026 Oct 27]. MMA-hosted copy.
- Teng ZS, Ser GTZ, Hong WH, Teo CH, Abdul Aziz YF, Vadivelu J; Malaysia MedEd Collaborative. Malaysian Medical Students’ Career Intention (MMSCI): a cross-sectional study. Hum Resour Health. 2024;22:59. doi:10.1186/s12960-024-00939-4. Primary source.
- Ministry of Health Singapore. Number of registered foreign doctors in Singapore. Parliamentary questions 3594 and 3595 [Internet]. 2022 Oct 20 [cited 2026 Oct 26]. Primary source.
- MOH Holdings. Clinical careers [Internet]. Singapore: MOH Holdings; [cited 2026 Oct 26]. Primary source.
- MOH Holdings. Medical careers [Internet]. Singapore: MOH Holdings; [cited 2026 Oct 26]. Primary source.
- SingHealth Polyclinics. Resident physician. Recruitment advertisement, requisition 2320 [Internet]. 2026 Oct 24 [cited 2026 Oct 26]. Primary source.